SpiderMan

Most people see it as an emotion based ban. or be part of the broadly defined "don't be a dick" rule.

This x 1000. Nobody has any right to try to control other peoples lives over a video game rivalry.

She was banned for it though, until someone else unbanned her a while later. Also, it was none of anyone's business to meddle in her personal life. It was a very childish move by someone who is obviously not a child

He was banned before most of the current player base joined, I think he should be given a second chance.

I think everybody would.

I agree, hope to see a follow up post in regards to this issue. ;D

Rest assured friends, the concerns brought up in this thread are not being swept under the rug and/or ignored. ;D

Here are a few clarifications: Explain toxicity in the context it was originally brought up. Who do you think is or was being toxic and why? Are the issues raised in the post with or without any merit? What is your opinion on said issues?

Beds aren't unique to P.nerd.nu , they've been in the game since Beta 1.3 February 22, 2011 more than 2 years ago.

It wouldnt be as much as most people think, the top creative mode server (800 players) gives everyone logblock rollback for their plot, and logblock wand everywhere else. The resource impact is minimal and reduces moderation tickets exponentially.

What about what the people who said what they did, shouldn't they be held liable for their own words, the impact to the community? Explain toxicity? Who is being toxic? Is the person whistleblowing worse than what they're whistleblowing about? also, what about the issues that were raised in the posts?

I've seen creative servers that give players logblock access within THEIR plot. It works great because it reduces moderation exponentially.

Are you implying this is not the case anymore? I think s/he came to that conclusion based on the leaked mod/admin chat logs. Their words were very clear.

What about what the people who said what they did, shouldn't they be held liable for their own words, the impact to the community? Explain toxicity? Who is being toxic? Is the person whistleblowing worse than what they're whistleblowing about? also, what about the issues that were raised in the posts?

I don't think Tharine can be blamed for what other people said about the community... Edit: I'd prefer a reply instead of downvotes, please.

Ah, thank you for clarifying. The actual chat logs prove that there is a players vs staff issue. It's made worse by the fact that the subcommunity exists and isn't transparent in any way or responsive to the changes that the player base suggests. Also: https://nerd.nu/forum/index.php?/topic/405-becoming-a-moderator-is-not-a-promotion/

Make it toggle-able. Easy Peasy

The contents of that chat room did more damage to the remaining community than her departure. Also, care to elaborate on the those threats? So by getting caught with your pants down, it means that you can no longer moderate efficiently on a minecraft server. Please note the usage of the word "we" below. Does that not seem like character assasination? Ah, you dont believe history has a direct bearing on how she is likely act towards the community... are you refering to the player community or the admin/mod subcommunity you mentioned earlier. Ah, the blaming the messenger. Also, your opinion has not changed my own opinion in the slightest. Really, you can't be serious? explain the following:

Edit: Instead of Downvoting, please reply, Thanks, -gsand ah, so those were her only 2 requests, the ones that caused her to ragequit. It doesn't make sense she would ragequit like that... I appreciated your apology the first time. The primary issue most players appear to have is the toxicity of those discussions. She was very meticulous in sanitizing² those logs. ² relatively From my perspective it appears to be mostly gossip. I'm sure you're capable of forming ideas all by yourself. A lot of people consider that to be one of the main problems.

How is she seeking to harm the community, please explain the words you are typing. Your attempt at character assasination is extremely obvious, by the way. You've provided no real reason for people to dislike her other than the fact that she posted logs of a video game server admin chat log. Also, I've known Tharine for considerably longer than you have, who are you to try to dictate my or anyone else's opinions about her. Also, this isn't the first time you've said trash like this, the first time you said it was in IRC, and you got called out immediately.

Yes, a lot of players believe that there is a double standard between actions made by admins and those done by players. The people who feel this way always seem to reference the following ban appeal. http://nerd.nu/archives/index.php?p=/discussion/18332/randomdoor-cyotie911/p1

According to her leaving thread, she still had the trust of the s players, who's trust do you think she broke? please elaborate. Which of her ideas were actually implemented?

Who do you think would win in a competitive Counter strike match between your father and mother?

:facepalm: :facepalm: The moment votifier gets installed on these servers is the moment a ton of people will quit. In the same fashion as Digg 4.0 :facepalm: :facepalm:

Too Exploitable. 9 Slots: Sharpness 5 Diamond Sword Protection 4 Diamond Helmet Protection 4 Diamond Chestplate Protection 4 Diamond Leggings Protection 4 Diamond Boots Stack of Diamond Blocks 16 Eyes of Ender Stack of Blaze Rods Stack of Carrots or Potatoes