Jump to content
Barlimore

Revision 21 Suggestionbox Responses

Recommended Posts

January 5th

Suggestion: Can we have some kind of event to distribute clues to help narrow down the location of the unfound spawners?

Our Response: We have plans to discuss the remaining custom spawners hidden in both the overworld and nether within the next padmin meeting this weekend. We'll follow up with our plan of action in our public meeting notes and go from there. Short answer - yes!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

January 8th

Suggestion: end crystal plugin should extinguish the fire before it converts the item to a drop

Our response: Thank you for your suggestion. End crystals are set up as close to vanilla as possible, without allowing them to cause grief. The persistent fire works as a partial replacement for the explosion you would experience in a normal game. At this time, we don't feel it's desirable to diverge from vanilla further, when end crystals can be crafted with relative ease.

 

Suggestion: op Lethal_Tree

Our Response: We already responded to this suggestion here. Please try to limit the number of joke submissions.

 

Suggestion: Make the /vote rewards apply to everyone from the same IP since you can only vote 1 time per household

Our Response: This particular suggestion is not one in which we can help with directly, so we will not be responding to it here. Instead, we have passed on the suggestion to the head admins where they will seek to respond to it accordingly in the head admin suggestionbox. Should you have lobby-specific suggestions, or head admin suggestions, running /suggestion-box on the lobby will go directly to them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

January 10th

Suggestion: start of this video as minigame - sphere randomly filled with air or TNT, some creepers start in the middle, your score is how many TNT you retrieve after <time>

Our Response: Thanks for the suggestion. We're not sure if the suggestion is for something on P, or for our minigames server, and we think you may have meant to include a video to demonstrate what you mean. Please get in contact with us to let us know what your intent was.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

January 10th

Suggestion: I had an idea to help promote community interaction! Address Book. It's like /place but for people. Allow players to mark a location they call home so other people can more easily find them. /address bob to be pointed towards bob's house

Our Response: Thank you for your suggestion - we do like to see new avenues opening up for community interaction! We do have a suggestion in response to your own suggestion; With the use of "/setwp <name> public" ( http://wiki.nerd.nu/wiki/PvE_Information_Guide#Waypoints ) you can set up a list of publicly accessible waypoints and collect them all in a post on the forums, or subreddit for people to easily find various homes which may not have a place marker on the map.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

January 12th

Suggestion: can /stand have ability to control view distance on the name...?

Our Response: With regards to view distance on the server, this is overseen by tech admins to ensure optimum server stability. We are not looking to have any form of view distance set manually for this reason.

 

Suggestion: redstone block tech admin doppels

Suggestion: hadmin and tadmin dopples should be special too. more heads and technical challenges!

Our Response: We felt that both of these suggestions were similar enough that we wanted to put a combined response together. Thank you both for putting out these ideas!

We have different doppelganger costs for padmin doppels as they directly feed into the costs for iron golem spawners. Other admin doppels do not feed into any special costs and we do not wish to extend any changes in the cost to any other doppels. In regards to other admins, they would potentially see increases to their own skull costs - when as players themselves, it wouldn't be fair for them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

January 12th

Suggestion: golem-soul-like drops for other blocks that can be traded at spawn for equally useless trophies

Our Response: We really like this suggestion and already have some ideas for implementing something like this into the next revision, as it would fit into the theme there. Thank you for sharing your thoughts on this idea!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

January 16th

Suggestion: doing a /pve (and similar) if you're already there should still reconnect you somehow

Our Response: Thank you for your submission. We are not looking to request tech admin time into this particular suggestion as reconnecting to P, while on the same server is currently possible either by disconnecting and reconnecting, or by running /lobby first.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

January 18th

Suggestion: Let us link boats uptogether like trains do so we can boat party travel

Suggestion: boat trains, that join up like trains!

Suggestion: boat trains

Our Response: Thank you, all three of you for submitting this suggestion! We think this could be a fun idea to include, and would be completely willing to consider any plugins which have this feature, for testing on pve-dev, and then submitted to the entire P community for discussion / feedback. We've yet to encounter a plugin which has this feature yet but if you find one, please send it our way!

 

Suggestion: Horse levelling should scale with the number of people on the horse

Our Response: Given that this means of travelling is an unintended bug, we will not be looking to implement this suggestion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

January 21st

Suggestion: Make rider capacity a levelable stat for horses. 2 diamond blocks fed=2 riders, 4 more diamond blocks=3 riders, 8 more diamond blocks=4 riders, etc

Our Response: Thank you for your suggestion, we've taken this into consideration based on the recent bug which has had groups of people sharing the same untamed horse.

For the moment, we will not be looking to request a permanent implementation of a feature such as this. We would be interested to learn of the consequences when two people who share poor connections are trying to share the same horse, and would prefer to avoid creating situations where one individual steering a horse could kill their passenger, creating new ways for pvp deaths to occur.

 

Suggestion: separate limits for rabbit colors (like sheep)

Our Response: We took some time to discuss your suggestion and have decided against implementing a change here. Moblimiter limits are in place via the tech admins to keep a handle on server stability, where there are sheep divided by colours as they provide a block resource, we do not see a resource benefit for requesting an increase to the moblimiter limits for rabbits.

We would instead recommend to use name tags to retain any rabbits that you wish to keep. Please be mindful that large quantities of animals do contribute to server entity lag as on occasion we do have to reach out to individuals who are breeding excessively.

 

Suggestion: add thelvadumee to the list of hunted ppl :smile:

Our Response: We do like the idea of having other people added to the roster of hunted people during admin hunts, though one of the primary issues we would encounter are all permission-related.

For example our creative admins currently have a more difficult experience getting set up for each life in the admin hunt. Additional steps are needed due to differing permissions on P. One of the other key concerns related to permissions would be that any admins who are hunting others to kill, would be able to see hunted people getting set up in the hunt arena - and this would provide a significant advantage.

Sadly, we do not see a way to make this happen at the moment.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

January 21st

Suggestion: re: jan 10 suggestion missing a link: I am pasting it here: https://youtu.be/CBeIq96sI3w?t=7

Suggestion: yes minigames server

Context (suggestion and response from Jan 10th):

Spoiler

 

Suggestion: start of this video as minigame - sphere randomly filled with air or TNT, some creepers start in the middle, your score is how many TNT you retrieve after <time>

Our Response: Thanks for the suggestion. We're not sure if the suggestion is for something on P, or for our minigames server, and we think you may have meant to include a video to demonstrate what you mean. Please get in contact with us to let us know what your intent was.

 

Our Response: Thank you very much for getting back to us - this video is a good demonstration of the gameplay of this type of event! We have passed this onto the head admins who oversee the minigames server - as a reminder, all suggestions for the head admins can be submitted directly from the lobby in between restarts, if you wish to take a more direct approach.

 

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

January 24th

Suggestion: for admin hunts: instead of dropping a shulker box, said box is auto-placed at their death site with the killer on admin perms. would allow them and only them to pick it up

Our Response: We took your suggestion under consideration as we can understand the frustration of putting effort into pursuing an admin, only to lose the prize box. It is for the same reason, that effort of pursuing an admin that we are not going to proceed with this particular suggestion.

During the admin hunts, we witness cases where the people who spend a lot of time chasing a single admin, possibly doing the most damage to them, don't always get the killing blow or the loot thereafter. If we were to award the shulker box just to the person who landed the killing blow, we could potentially be cheating another player out of a prize. There's no easy way to judge this fairly and so, provided the admin hunts continue, we have opted to retain 'luck of the draw' for both kills and loot, rather than have people prevail upon our judgement at every admin kill.

 


Suggestion: pvp enabled region closed off from the rest of the map at a corner? nerd.nu does not facilitate pvp properly anymore and therefore loses potential players

Our Response: We can certainly see an appetite from some to expand the reach of the pvp elements on Nerd. From our understanding of the player versus environment server, we are not the server to expand into this area. P is intended to be largely open to exploration, where people only need to worry about the environment and mobs themselves as a threat.

While we are not going to pursue this suggestion ourselves, we would recommend submitting this idea, or others related to pvp combat, with the head admins (the suggestion box on the lobby will go directly to them). Keep in mind though that all pvp-orientated servers have already been switched off, or has no current activity.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

January 26th

Suggestion: /hmount command to put you on your horse if it is close enough (as a work around for the invisible horse bug)

Our Response: We understand the frustration of horses deciding to make a great escape through invisibility as we experience this often too. However, given that moving 10-15 chunks away and returning, or simply relogging can fix this issue, we don't feel that it is worth requesting tech admin time to pursue another workaround to this.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

January 31st

Suggestion: /place has grown huge, can we have /place nether and /place overworld to make the list easier to parse without huge chat scrollback?

Our Response: For the moment, we're not looking to make any further changes to place as the next step is likely for it to become a plugin of its own, where new features can be included. During that process, we'll ensure that your feedback is included in the feature-list.

(edit: Just an added reminder that you can run /place <setname> to return only the list of places associated with a particular set, such as /place settlements )

Suggestion: A (streaming) tag on server list like the (afk) tag. That way people can know who's live and streamers don't have to spam out links to remind people

Our Response: Thank you for your suggestion, we do see a need to have something that would better identify people who are streaming, though we don't feel that tags would be the right way forward with P, given how we avoid ranks.

However, we've put forward a new command for P, for the tech admins to consider which would address the points in your suggestion. Hopefully the command works out, and if it does, we'll be shouting about it further down the line.

Edited by Barlimore

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

February 2nd

Suggestions: pvp in lobby

&

mini PVP areas in the loby

Our Response: Thank you for submitting these suggestions, while we have no control over the lobby, we have passed on both of these suggestions to the head admin team who will respond to these on their suggestion box topic in future. Just as a reminder, the suggestion box is active in the lobby too, if you'd prefer to submit suggestions directly to the head admins.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

February 3rd

Suggestion: I wanted to ask if you could make the moblimiter thing modreqable , i dont want massive farms but things like slime chunks (slime cull is 4 oof) or some other animal farms, it would be good if you could modreq it and ask to have almost 10

Our Response: Thank you for your suggestion, we are happy to review specific requests with regards to moblimiter but this is not something we currently see a need to adjust in the case of slimes. From our interpretation of your suggestion, we gather that a clarification may be worth making in terms of mob spawning and moblimiter. Moblimiter will not prevent slimes from spawning in numbers greater than 4, the issue is that when on a multiplayer server, the available mob spawning is spread across the loaded chunks, so it is typically better to visit the custom slime spawners and their respective grinders in these cases.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

February 4th

Suggestion: Put any future zombie pigman spawners in the overworld so AFK players don't break nether spawn rates.

Our Response: Thank you for your feedback. Revision 22 decisions have already been made but this feedback was submitted during the mid-revision feedback topics and prior, so we have considered this for the next revision.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

February 4th

Suggestion: trainboats

Our Response: We have already received and responded to this suggestion here!

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

February 12th

Suggestion: add dungoens to the outer end islands to make the end more interesting plss

Our Response: Thank you for your suggestion! We have already begun work on revision 22, so any suggestions for map-related changes and such are already locked down.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×